AyersOnline.com
Home > Ayers' Editorials > Classic Columns

Home E-Mail Search

Featured Column
Classic Columns
Other Writings
Aboout the Author

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Declining Cost of Living
by


Every summer I promise myself I'll get to the bottom of my huge pile of things to read. This year, I've made a sizeable dent in it, but there's still more pile left than summer.

One of the things in the pile was the 1997 annual report of the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas. It contained a study I wanted to read by W. Michael Cox, vice president and economic advisor of the Dallas Fed and Richard Alm called "Time Well Spent: The Declining Real Cost of Living in America"

The study contradicts the conventional wisdom that the cost of living is increasing. Sure, prices have gone up leaving penny candy and five and dime stores just figures of speech.

But the authors claim the real cost of living shouldn't be measured in dollars and cents since money is an imperfect standard. Even inflation adjusted dollars miss the mark since they don't account for increases in productivity.

The study argues that what really matters isn't what something costs in money. Money prices by themselves don't mean a whole lot. What matters is what it costs in time. In other words, time is money.

A hundred years ago, you could buy a pair of stockings for 25 cents. That sounds cheap until you realize the average worker only earned 14.8 cents an hour. It took 1 hour and 41 minutes worth of work just to buy one hot, itchy pair. Today, you can buy a much better pair for 18 minutes of work.

And so our economy goes. The prices of band new products usually put you in sticker-shock. Before long though, prices fall and what used to be a luxury worthy of "Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous" becomes a part of the average household.

The High Cost of Living, 1897 Style
Item
1897 Sears
Catalog Price
1997 Work-
Equivalent Price
1 lb. Box baking soda $      0.06 $      5.34
Bicycle $    24.95 $2221.90
250 manilla envelopes $      0.35 $    31.17
Webster's Dictionary $      0.70 $    62.34
12 Pencils $      0.14 $    12.47
Telephone $    13.50 $1202.23
Ironing Board $      0.60 $    53.43
1 karat Diamond Ring $    74.00 $6590.00
9" Steel Scissors $      0.75 $     66.79

At one time, electricity, indoor plumbing and telephones were only found among the well-heeled. Today, they're considered an American birthright.

Since every year it takes less work time to buy most of the things we want, the cost of living is actually declining.

Of course, not everything is cheaper. The price of a college education in work hours, for both private and public schools, is about double what it was in 1979.

For the most part though, our economy is creating a better life for all of us. Economist Joseph Schumpeter said, "Queen Elizabeth owned silk stockings. The capitalist achievement does not typically consist in providing more silk stockings for queens but in bringing them within reach of factory girls in return for steadily decreasing amounts of effort."

Not many of us have lots of money but we're all gifted with the currency of time. If trends continue, it appears as if our time is being well spent.

The Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas has made Time Well Spent: The Declining Real Cost of Living in America available online. The publication is loaded with charts and graphs too!

© Copyright Deborah A. Ayers 1998. All rights reserved.

Copyright © Deborah A. Ayers
All rights reserved.